RSS: RSS Feed Icon

I just finished Cheap: The High Cost of Discount Culture by Ellen Ruppel Shell and I am now both disgusted and totally freaked out. Ed is hosting a round table discussion on this one in the coming weeks which I am a part of so I won't go into too much detail here but really, Shell has done an outstanding job of bringing together all the facets of our need to buy cheap: food, clothing, furniture, etc. She doesn't just talk Wal-mart (in fact she doesn't talk much about Wal-mart at all) but she does talk IKEA and Red Lobster and China and the history of discount shopping in our country (Woolworths, etc.) which is truly fascinating. Beyond all the info though, Shell's writing style is utterly and completely top notch. This is popular history/culture at its finest and after you read it, you will approach every single purchase you make with a high level of suspicion.

We have been roundly manipulated folks, for our entire lives. And while we all kinda know it, you have to read Cheap to really appreciate it. Staggering stuff.

I read a lot of biographies where I think the subject is interesting and wished that I could have been the one to research their life, read their letters, peek behind all the dusty corners of their secrets and mysteries. (I'd give you some examples but the list would be ridiculously long.) It is rare that I read one where I wish the person was my friend however - where I really want to just live down the road, have an occasional burger and maybe take a weekly walk with him. But that's exactly what I thought as I read Ashley Bryan: Words to My Life's Song. It's the coolest book about the coolest artist and I just loved it and I love him. And I want Ashley Bryan to be my friend.

Unfortunately he lives on the other side of the country but maybe we could be pen pals or something.

Ashley Bryan is an award winning illustrator who has had a life of loving art. He has written this book both as a memoir of growing up and as an invitation to visit his current life. It's a very unusual mesh of past and present but it works - and the photos of his puppets and stained glass along with reproductions of his illustrations are fabulous. But mostly it is the joy in which he lives that made me like him so much. It's a picture book bio (58 pgs) but works for any audience interested in the lives of artists, African Americans, and all around cool people. There aren't enough cool people in the world; we should make celebrating them a national priority. (My formal review is up in the new issue of Eclectica.)

Cricket Man by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor strikes me as a book that might not have been published if it was written by a less known author. Don't get me wrong, it is well written and has a compelling protagonist in young Kenny but it just doesn't quite seem to know what it wants to be about and then there is such a massive curveball thrown in the final pages that the reader is left more than a bit shocked. It's one thing to figure out the truth about Bruce Willis in The Sixth Sense - which just makes perfect sense in retrospect - and it's a whole other deal to think you're reading a sweet coming-of-age story about a boy learning to follow his instincts and buck authority and then...well....let's just say we've very nearly got a dumpster baby involved and leave it at that.

Cricket Man (the title refers to Kenny's determination to save crickets from drowning in his backyard pool) is for MG readers but it really doesn't do anything to help them with the very issues raised by the ending. And also, having known a family quite closely who went through a similar situation, the emotions of everyone involved don't ring true. It's just too pat for lack of a better word and it also doesn't fit with everything that came before it. I felt like I read the ending for an entirely different book - it's just too suddenly intense. I'd love to hear from anyone else who read it to see what they think.

In other reading news, Dara Torres apparently had bulimia when she first went to the Olympics but managed to medal anyway. She is also very competitive (which makes sense) but I wish her book had been more detailed about her life rather than just her Olympic career and decisions. It's actually pretty short when you consider it covers 25 years. HerStoria sounds like excellent history for girl geeks. The bummer is that it is from Britain so the sub cost is steep ($48 for 4 issues).But there is some decent content on the web site as well. ("Women and Madness" is certainly worth a look.) Andrea Barrett is interviewed in the last Believer - haven't read it yet, but plan to soon.

Anila's Journey is a sweet story set in historic India that is a slightly more grown-up companion to fans of The Evolution of Calpurnia Tate. Girl naturalists are certainly a good thing to writer about. (Anila will be in my August column.) And in the pantheon of woman travelers to Africa, I somehow missed Kenyan conservationist and filmmaker Joan Thorpe Root but will be seeking out the book on her life and death after reading Donna Seaman's review in Booklist. Wildflower by Mark Seal sounds amazing:

In this riveting portrait, Seal incisively tracks Joan’s affinity for the wild from her birth in Nairobi in 1932 to helping her intrepid father manage Kenya’s first photo safaris, to her risky work with her husband, the innovative filmmaker and infamous daredevil Alan Root. Lovely, shy, and unflappable, Joan did everything from organizing their ambitious expeditions to dancing in front of a spitting cobra so Alan could film an attack. The messy end of their marriage was devastating to Joan, as was the environmental nightmare that engulfed her cherished home and animal refuge on Lake Naivasha, as Kenya’s flower industry consumed and polluted the landscape and poachers decimated fish and wildlife. Joan struggled heroically to protect this precious ecosystem but became ensnared in a net of social crises and crime.

She was murdered in her home in January 2006.

Finally, be sure to check out Amy's book drive for Beth Kephart's new book, Nothing But Ghosts. The drive run through Friday and is in support of a lovely YA title. My formal review of Ghosts will appear in my July column.

[Let's see, I received Cheap from the pub for the round table discussion which is not really a review but still came from the pub. Ashley Bryan, Cricket Man, Anila's Journey and Nothing But Ghosts all came from the pubs. All others are personal acquisitions/or borrowed or books I don't have and have not read but read about!]

comments

I would call Cricket Man young YA, not middle grade, but your point is still well made. My 12 year old son devoured it, but he said, "Some of it was weird. I didn't get some of the parts with the girl." Translation: it was a perfect book for preteen boys that shifted itself into something way beyond the average preteen boy's comprehension. (Well, I just went back and reread what he said when we reviewed it together for my blog, and maybe "beyond his comprehension" is overstating it).

You know Ali, you're right. I think when I saw it as juvenile fiction I thought it was more MG than YA. In some places it says 12-17, in others 7-9th grade. Very confusing.

I think the bigger problem with it is what you point out - it's great for boys around 12 & up. It's a great "boy stands up for himself" title for the first three quarters and he does seem to just want to be friends with the girl but then the end just blows it all apart. It does not fit at all and the ending would be very disappointing to pretty much all 12 year old boys. It doesn't work - it's seems like a book that doesn't know what it wants to be which is a disappointment.

I think I should a.) first own all the Ashley Bryan books ever written, and b.)rub it in that I got to be at a conference where he spoke. But I'm such a big nerd I only sat near him and gazed adoringly. He. Is. Awesome.

Also: cheap sounds like something I *DON'T* want to read, and know I should. I've been learning, little by little, what actual quality means, and it's something for which you sometimes have to pay. I'm learning to go without until I can get quality... but I'd love to know the dirt on Ikea. Can't wait for both the book and the roundtable.

I totally want to read Cheap. It's utterly true that as large corporations satisfy our demand for cheap stuff, we buy and buy and think smugly to ourselves how accessible the "good life" is, not realizing the "good life" is actually being crushed beneath the heels of the corporations that are selling us the cheap stuff. This sounds like an amazing book, and one that needed to be written, although I'm sure it won't be bought and read nearly as much as it ought to be.

Ed is running the round table the week of July 16th (I believe). You guys need to check it out and get everyone's opinions on it and see how amazing the book is. What was most interesting to me is that we have literally been programmed to believe cheap is better - even though we know that cheap things will not last. So IKEA's $70 bookcase that won't stand up to five years of heavy use is a bargain as opposed to a $200 bookcase that will last 10 years or a more expensive lifetime investment.

And don't even get me started on sustainable logging practices and fair work rules. If you thought unions were so 20th century, then you need to see what life is like without them. (This is where Wal-mart does get mentioned - and Caterpillar.)

It's a stunner, plain and simple.

Post a comment

Comment preview:




Newest Colleen in Lit World